Batman Arkham City Identity Theft Locations and Victim Guide

The Identity Theft side mission in Batman: Arkham City stands out as one of the most compelling psychological mysteries in the game. Players must step into the boots of the World's Greatest Detective to track down a serial killer operating within the prison walls. Finding each crime scene requires a keen eye and careful exploration across the dangerous streets of Gotham.
The Initial Discovery in the Industrial District
The dark investigation begins when Batman stumbles upon the first victim in the eastern section of the Industrial District. The body is located in a secluded alleyway, wrapped carefully in bloodied bandages with the face completely removed. Activating Detective Mode allows players to scan the immediate area for forensic evidence and strange chemical traces left behind by the killer.
After completing the analysis, Oracle provides technical data that suggests a pattern is starting to emerge within the city. Players should note that the second crime scene will not trigger immediately until further progress is made in the main story. Exploring other areas of the map can help pass the time while waiting for the next radio report.
Tracking the Second Victim Near the Bowery
The grim trail picks up again in the Bowery region, specifically in a narrow path just north of the subway entrance. This second victim matches the exact modus operandi of the first encounter, confirming that a serial killer is on the loose. Players need to locate a critical witness nearby who claims to have seen Bruce Wayne committing the horrific crime.
Scanning the surrounding pavement reveals a distinct trail of bleach used to sanitize the murder weapon. Following these chemical stains requires constant use of the cowl's forensic scanner through the winding alleys. This puzzle highlights the intricate detective mechanics that make the Arkham series so memorable for comic fans.
The Final Clues and the Identity of Hush
The third crime scene manifests in the western portion of the city, tucked away near the Ace Chemicals building. Investigating this final location provides the conclusive biometric data needed to locate the killer's secret operating base. A hidden apartment lockbox becomes accessible once all three pieces of forensic evidence are successfully cataloged.
Entering the hideout triggers a tense cinematic sequence that reveals Thomas Elliot, also known as Hush, as the mastermind behind the plot. He explains his complex motivation for stealing the facial features of various inmates to exact revenge on the Wayne family. Concluding this mission leaves an ominous cliffhanger that sets up future conflicts in the dark knight's universe.